Английская Википедия:Holy War and Human Bondage
Шаблон:Italictitle Holy War and Human Bondage: Tales of Christian‐Muslim Slavery in the Early‐Modern Mediterranean is a 2009 non-fiction book by Robert Davis, published by Praeger.
It discusses intra-Christian slavery and slavery of Muslims by Christians. According to Jeff Grabmeier of Ohio State University, the book received less overall attention compared to Christian Slaves, Muslim Masters.[1]
Eric R. Dursteler of Brigham Young University stated that the work "stands on its own and presents a more expansive and comprehensive, yet accessible, synthetic treatment of" its topic.[2] Dursteler stated that since several people taking slaves did not discriminate by religion on whether to take slaves, the "provocative" title "is a bit misleading."[2]
Content
Some chapters are longer and some are shorter, content characterized by Dursteler as "vignettes".[2]
According to Dursteler, "there is a solidly European focus to the book",[2] and that it is "only lightly informed by relevant Ottoman scholarship".[3] Consequently, the amount of content related to slaves who followed Islam is less compared to the content about slaves who followed Christianity.[2]
Reception
Dursteler had an overall favorable reception and that his criticisms were "relatively minor quibbles".[3]
Maria Fusaro of the University of Exeter, citing the one page-long "works cited", which she characterized as "exceedingly short", concluded that the book is "highly problematic".[4] According to Fusaro, while Davis stated in the introduction that he wished to tailor his work to a non-academic audience, Davis may have been conflicted on whether to do so.[4]
References
Notes
Further reading
External links
