Английская Википедия:Dharma transmission
Шаблон:Short description Шаблон:See also Шаблон:Zen Buddhism Шаблон:Western Buddhism In Chan and Zen Buddhism, dharma transmission is a custom in which a person is established as a "successor in an unbroken lineage of teachers and disciples, a spiritual 'bloodline' (kechimyaku) theoretically traced back to the Buddha himself."[1] The dharma lineage reflects the importance of family-structures in ancient China, and forms a symbolic and ritual recreation of this system for the monastical "family".Шаблон:Sfn
In Rinzai-Zen, inka shōmei is ideally "the formal recognition of Zen's deepest realisation",Шаблон:Sfn but practically it is being used for the transmission of the "true lineage" of the masters (shike) of the training halls.Шаблон:Sfn There are only about fifty[web 1] to eighty[web 2] of such inka shōmei-bearers in Japan.
In Sōtō-Zen, dharma transmission is referred to as shiho, and further training is required to become an oshō.[web 3]
History
The notion and practice of Dharma Transmission developed early in the history of Chan, as a means to gain credibilityШаблон:Sfn and to foster institutional ties among the members of the Chan community.Шаблон:Sfn Charts of dharma-lineages were developed, which represented the continuity of the Buddhist dharma. Originally these lineages only included the Chinese Patriarchs, but they were later extended to twenty-eight Indian Patriarchs and seven Buddhas.Шаблон:Sfn
Chan lineage
The Chan tradition developed from the established tradition of "Canonical Buddhism",Шаблон:Sfn which "remained normative for all later Chinese Buddhism".Шаблон:Sfn It was established by the end of the sixth century, as a result of the Chinese developing understanding of Buddhism in the previous centuries.Шаблон:SfnШаблон:Sfn
One of the inventions of this Canonical Buddhism were transmission lists, a literary device to establish a lineage. Both Tiantai and Chan took over this literary device, to lend authority to those developing traditions, and guarantee its authenticity:Шаблон:SfnШаблон:Sfn Шаблон:Quote
The concept of dharma transmission took shape during the Tang period, when establishing the right teachings became important, to safeguard the authority of specific schools.Шаблон:Sfn The emerging Zen-tradition developed the Transmission of the Lamp-genre, in which lineages from Shakyamuni Buddha up to their own times were described.Шаблон:Sfn
Another literary device for establishing those traditions was given by the Kao-seng-chuan (Biographies of Eminent Monks), compiled around 530.Шаблон:Sfn The Chan-tradition developed its own corpus in this genre, with works such as Anthology of the Patriarchal Hall (952) and the Jingde Records of the Transmission of the Lamp (published 1004). McRae considers Dumoulin's A History of Zen to be a modern example of this genre, disguised as scientific history.Шаблон:Sfn
Chinese patriarchs
The Chan lineages picture the semi-legendary monk Bodhidharma as the patriarch who brought Chan to China. Only scarce historical information is available about him, but his hagiography developed when the Chan tradition grew stronger and gained prominence in the early 8th century.
Six Chinese patriarchs
By this time a lineage of the six ancestral founders of Chan in China was developed.Шаблон:Sfn In the late 8th century, under the influence of Huineng's student Shenhui, the traditional form of this lineage had been established:Шаблон:Sfn
- Bodhidharma (Шаблон:Lang) ca. 440 – ca. 528
- Huike (Шаблон:Lang) 487–593
- Sengcan (Шаблон:Lang) ?–606
- Daoxin (Шаблон:Lang) 580–651
- Hongren (Шаблон:Lang) 601–674
- Huineng (Шаблон:Lang) 638–713
Shenhui and Huineng
According to tradition, the sixth and last ancestral founder, Huineng (惠能; 638–713), was one of the giants of Chan history, and all surviving schools regard him as their ancestor. The dramatic story of Huineng's life tells that there was a controversy over his claim to the title of patriarch. After being chosen by Hongren, the fifth ancestral founder, Huineng had to flee by night to Nanhua Temple in the south to avoid the wrath of Hongren's jealous senior disciples.
Modern scholarship, however, has questioned this narrative. Historic research reveals that this story was created around the middle of the 8th century, beginning in 731 by Shenhui, a successor to Huineng, to win influence at the Imperial Court. He claimed Huineng to be the successor of Hongren instead of the then publicly recognized successor Shenxiu.Шаблон:Sfn In 745 Shenhui was invited to take up residence in the Ho-tse temple in Luoyang. In 753 he fell out of grace, and had to leave the capital to go into exile. The most prominent of the successors of his lineage was Guifeng ZongmiШаблон:Sfn According to Zongmi, Shenhui's approach was officially sanctioned in 796, when "an imperial commission determined that the Southern line of Chan represented the orthodox transmission and established Shen-hui as the seventh patriarch, placing an inscription to that effect in the Shen-lung temple".Шаблон:Sfn
Doctrinally the Southern School is associated with the teaching that enlightenment is sudden, while the Northern School is associated with the teaching that enlightenment is gradual. This was a polemical exaggeration, since both schools were derived from the same tradition, and the so-called Southern School incorporated many teachings of the more influential Northern School.Шаблон:Sfn Eventually both schools died out, but the influence of Shenhui was so immense that all later Chan schools traced their origin to Huineng, and "sudden enlightenment" became a standard doctrine of Chan.Шаблон:Sfn
Indian Patriarchs
In later writings this lineage was extended to include twenty-eight Indian patriarchs. In the Song of Enlightenment (證道歌 Zhèngdào gē) of Yongjia Xuanjue (永嘉玄覺, 665–713), one of the chief disciples of Huìnéng, it is written that Bodhidharma was the 28th patriarch in a line of descent from Mahākāśyapa, a disciple of Śākyamuni Buddha, and the first patriarch of Chán Buddhism.Шаблон:Sfn
Twenty-eight Indian Patriarchs
Keizan's Transmission of the Light gives twenty-eight patriarchs up to and including Bodhidharma in this transmission:Шаблон:SfnШаблон:SfnШаблон:Refn
Шаблон:Zen Lineage 28 Patriarchs
Mahākāśyapa
According to the traditional Chan accounts, the first Dharma transmission occurred as described in the Flower Sermon. The Buddha held up a golden lotus flower before an assembly of "gods and men". None who were in attendance showed any sign of understanding except his disciple Mahākāśyapa, who offered only a smile. The Buddha then said, Шаблон:Quote
Function
Though dharma transmission implies the acknowledgement of insight into the teachings of Buddhism as understood by the Zen tradition, especially seeing into one's true nature, dharma transmission is also a means to establish a person into the Zen tradition:Шаблон:Sfn Шаблон:Quote
The dharma lineage reflects the importance of family-structures in ancient China, and forms a symbolic and ritual recreation of this system for the monastical "family".Шаблон:Sfn
Esoteric and exoteric transmission
According to Borup the emphasis on 'mind to mind transmission' is a form of esoteric transmission, in which "the tradition and the enlightened mind is transmitted face to face".Шаблон:Sfn Metaphorically this can be described as the transmission of a flame from one candle to another candle,Шаблон:Sfn or the transmission from one vein to another.Шаблон:Sfn In exoteric transmission the requirement is "direct access to the teaching through a personal discovery of one's self. This type of transmission and identification is symbolized by the discovery of a shining lantern, or a mirror."Шаблон:Sfn
This polarity is recognizable in the emphasis that the Zen-tradition puts on maintaining the correct Dharma transmission, while simultaneously stressing seeing into one's nature: Шаблон:Quote
Nevertheless, while the Zen tradition has always stressed the importance of formal Dharma transmission, there are well known examples of Mushi dokugo, such as Nōnin, Jinul and Suzuki Shōsan who attained awakening on their own, though all of them were familiar with the Zen-teachings.
Family structure
According to Bodiford, "Zen is the predominant form of Buddhism because of dharma transmission":Шаблон:Sfn Шаблон:Quote
Bodiford distinguishes seven dimensions which are discernible in both family relationships and in dharma lineages:
- Ancestral dimension: "Ancestors (so) constitute a fundamental source of power".Шаблон:Sfn Performing rituals in honour of the ancestors keeps them in high regard "among the living".Шаблон:Sfn
- Biological dimension: the dharma lineage creates (spiritual) offspring, just as the family creates new life.Шаблон:Sfn
- Linguistic dimension: dharma heirs receive new names, which reflect their tie to the dharma 'family'.Шаблон:Sfn
- Ritual dimension: rituals confirm the family relationships. One's teacher is honored in rituals, as are deceased teachers.Шаблон:Sfn
- Legal dimension: teachers have the obligation to discipline their students, just as students have the obligation to obey their teachers.Шаблон:Sfn
- Institutional and financial dimension: dharma heirs have an obligation to support their home temple, both financially and ritually.Шаблон:Sfn
- Temporal dimension: long-term relationships foster the previous dimensions.Шаблон:Sfn
The family-model is easier recognized when East Asian languages are being used, because the same terminology is used to describe both earthly and spiritual family relations.Шаблон:Sfn
Dharma transmission is both concrete and abstract:Шаблон:Sfn Шаблон:Quote
This feature gives dharma transmission a great flexibility:Шаблон:Sfn Шаблон:Quote
Contemporary use in the Chan and Zen traditions
Within the various Chan and Zen traditions, dharma transmission got various meanings. A difference is made in most schools between Шаблон:Quote
Chinese Chan
Traditional Chinese Chan still exists in China, Taiwan and Hong Kong, though it is less known in the west than Japanese Zen.
In the Chinese Buddhist tradition, there are 3 systems of transmission:[web 4]
- Tonsure system: a person becomes tonsured as a novice monastic under the Master's school. He or she is given a Dharma name (Шаблон:Linktext) at the time of tonsure based on the Master's lineage. This name is also called "the outer name (Шаблон:Linktext)" because it is used by all people to address the novice. This name is used for life. At the same time, the Master will give the novice sramanera (or sramanerika) ten precepts.
- Ordination system: a novice will become fully ordained as a Bhikṣu monk or Bhikṣuni nun with the Triple Platform Ordination (Observing the Śrāmanera, Bhikṣu and Bodhisattva precepts). This ordination must be presided by ten senior monks with at least ten years of seniority with a pure practice in upholding the monastic precepts. In this ceremony, the ten witnessing masters represent the Triple Gem accepting the novice into the Sangha. At this time, another Dharma name (Шаблон:Linktext) is given. This name is called "precept name (Шаблон:Linktext) or inner name (Шаблон:Linktext)" because it is used only by one's Master. This name represents the novice's precept lineage transmission.
- Dharma transmission system:Шаблон:SfnШаблон:Sfn This system upholds the Treasury of the True Dharma Eye through the generations of transmission. This is the Mind-to-Mind seal of the Dharma that is beyond the scriptures. At this time, another Dharma name is given. This is also called "the inner name" and used only by one's Master. This name represents the novice's Dharma lineage transmission. After receiving this name, one will use this name instead of the name received during precept ordination to write one's Dharma name (Inner Name)(Outer Name).
It is customary to refer to one's own tonsure Master as "Gracious Master", precept Master as "Root Master" and Dharma transmission Master as "Venerable Master". In Chinese Buddhism, these 3 systems are separate and are not performed by the same Masters. Moreover, due to the strong emphasis on the Dharma, when a person receives Dharma transmission, he or she is recognized as that Chán Master's Dharma son or daughter. Lay Buddhists may also receive this Dharma transmission, but this is very rare and with very few incidences. Most of the monks and nuns who received transmission have already been tonsured and ordained by other Masters.
Rinzai
All Rinzai lineages pass through Hakuin Ekaku, the 18th century revivalist, who considered himself to be an heir of Shoju Rojin (Shoju Ronin, Dokyu Etan, 1642–1721), though Hakuin never received formal recognition of his insight from Shoju Rojin, let alone transmission of his lineage,Шаблон:Sfn nor from any other teacher.[web 5] When he was installed as head priest of Shōin-ji in 1718, he had the title of Dai-ichiza, "First Monk":Шаблон:Sfn Шаблон:Quote
All contemporary Rinzai-lineages stem formally from Inzan Ien (1751–1814) and Takuju Kosen (1760–1833),Шаблон:SfnШаблон:Sfn both students of Gasan Jito (1727–1797). Gasan is considered to be a dharma heir of Hakuin, though "he did not belong to the close circle of disciples and was probably not even one of Hakuin's dharma heirs".Шаблон:Sfn
Through Hakuin, all contemporary Japanese Rinzai-lineages relate themselves to the Ōtōkan lineage, brought to Japan in 1267 by Nanpo Jomyo, who received dharma transmission in China in 1265.[web 6]
Insight and succession
In the Rinzai school, a difference is made between acknowledgement of insight and succession in the organisation: Шаблон:Quote
According to Mohr, Шаблон:Quote
The most common form of transmission in Rinzai Zen is the acknowledgement that one has stayed in the monastery for a certain amount of time, and may later become a temple priest.Шаблон:Sfn
Further practice
After finishing koan-study, further practice is necessary: Шаблон:Quote
Inka shōmei
Common transmission does not include inka shōmei. Ideally inka shōmei is "the formal recognition of Zen's deepest realisation",Шаблон:Sfn but practically it is being used for transmission of the "true lineage" of the masters (shike) of the training halls.Шаблон:Sfn Training halls are temples which are authorised for further training after being qualified as a temple priest.
There are only about fifty[web 1] to eighty[web 2] such inka shōmei-bearers in Japan: Шаблон:Quote
According to roshi Sokun Tsushimoto, the title of roshi is equivalent to Zen master and shike:[2] Шаблон:Quote
A qualified Zen master bestows inka only upon "those select few"Шаблон:Sfn who have successfully completed the entire Rinzai koan curriculum,Шаблон:Sfn[3]Шаблон:Sfn and "are eligible to serve as sōdō roshi,Шаблон:Sfn that is, master of a training hall, in distinction from a common temple: Шаблон:Quote
According to roshi Sokun Tsushimoto, Шаблон:Quote
Шаблон:Nihongo (Korean: Inga) literally means "the legitimate seal of clearly furnished proof":Шаблон:Sfn Шаблон:Quote
The right-hand portion of the seal was given to an individual who would then work by authority of the emperor, while the emperor himself would retain the left-hand portion. In ancient times inka usually came in the form of an actual document, but this practice is no longer commonplace.[4]
Sōtō
In Sōtō, dharma transmission is the acknowledgement of the ties between teacher and student. It has been subject to changes over the history of the Sōtō-school.Шаблон:Sfn
Though Dōgen emphasized the importance of the purity of the teachings, and highly valued lineage and dharma transmission, the Sōtō-school has its origins in various lineages and dharma transmissions.Шаблон:Sfn Dogen received dharma transmission from his Chinese teacher Rujing, with whom he studied two years, but in medieval Sōtō he was also considered to be a dharma heir of Myōzen, a Rinzai-teacher, with whom he studied eight years.Шаблон:Sfn And Tettsū Gikai, the dharma-grandson of Dogen, was also lineage-holder of Nōnin, the founder of the Dharuma-shu, also a Rinzai-school.Шаблон:Sfn Gikai passed this lineage over to Keizan, who thereby was also lineage-holder in at least two lineages.Шаблон:Sfn
To make the history of Sōtō even more complicated, the Caodong-lineage that Dogen inherited through Rujing was passed on previously from the Caodong-master Dayang Jingxuan to Touzi Yiqing via the Rinzai-master Fushan Fayuan. Fushan Fayuan had once studied under Dayang Jingxuan. When Jingxuan died Fayuan had received Jingxuan's "portrait, robe, and a verse that expressed his teaching",Шаблон:Sfn promising "to pass them on to a suitable successor". Fayuan chose his student Touzi Yiqing to inherit this lineage,Шаблон:Sfn a fact that was acknowledged in Keizan's Denkoroku, but "[i]n the standard versions of Dogen's writings, however, all direct references to Yiqing's indirect succession have been eliminated".Шаблон:Sfn
Criteria
Manzan Dokahu (1636–1714), a Sōtō reformer, Шаблон:Quote
According to Manzan, even an unenlightened student could receive dharma transmission: Шаблон:Quote
In Sōtō-zen, since Manzan Dokahu, two criteria are applied for dharma transmission:
- Isshi inshō – "Exclusive authentication from no more than one teacher".Шаблон:Sfn This criterion "prohibits clerics inheriting more than one lineage"Шаблон:Sfn
- Menju shihō – "Face-to-face bestowal of succession".Шаблон:Sfn This criterion "prohibits conferral by proxy, conferral at a distance to strangers, or posthumous conferral".Шаблон:SfnШаблон:Refn
Status
In contrast to the status that dharma transmission has begotten in the west, in Sōtō it has a relatively low status: Шаблон:Quote
To supervise the training of monks, further qualifications are necessary: Шаблон:Quote
The duties which come with this full qualification were not always appreciated. In the medieval organisation of the Sōtō-shu, when rotation of abbotship was the norm. Dharma transmission at a branch temple obliged one to serve at least one term as abbot at the main temple. Abbotship gave severe duties, and financial burdens, for which reason many tried to avoid the responsibility of abbotship:Шаблон:Sfn Шаблон:Quote
Spiritual realization
The Sōtō-shu also confers inka shōmyō (or inshō) "[granting] the seal of approval to a realization of enlightenment",Шаблон:Sfn upon students. This is an Шаблон:Quote
Dharma transmission is part of the maintenance of the Sōtō-institutions. Authority and temple-property are handed down, often from father to son.Шаблон:Sfn It is not a guarantee for spiritual attainment: Шаблон:Quote
Shiho
Dharma transmission is also called shiho.Шаблон:Sfn In the Sōtō school a student receives Dharma transmission during a denbō ceremony, which is the last ceremony of their shiho ceremony: Шаблон:Quote
Muhō Noelke, the German-born former abbot of the temple Antai-ji, describes his understanding of shiho: Шаблон:Quote
Shiho is done "one-to-one in the abbot's quarters (hojo)".[web 3] Three handwritten documents certify the dharma transmission; Шаблон:Quote
The procedure has to take place only once in one's life, and binds the student to the teacher forever: Шаблон:Quote
If a students does not have the feeling he wants to be tied to this teacher for the rest of his life, he may refuse to take dharma transmission from this particular teacher.[web 3] Since the time of Manzan Dokahu (1636–1714), multiple dharma transmissions are impossible in Sōtō Zen.[web 3]Шаблон:Sfn
Further study
According to Muho Noelke, dharma transmission marks the beginning of the real learning: Шаблон:Quote
After Dharma transmission one has become a member of the "blood line" of Zen, but is not yet qualified as an Oshō. After the ten-e and zuise ceremonies, one is qualified as an oshō. There-after one has to practice for some time, at least six months, in an sôdô-ango, an officially recognized Sōtō-shu training centre.[web 7]
After that one can start to work in a temple. The newly acquired status is confirmed in the kyoshi-honin ceremony. There-after follows the first practice-period in one's own temple, with the aid of a susho (head monk). This is followed by the Jushoku-himei ceremony, which confirms one's status as dai-oshō.[web 7]
Sanbo Kyodan
The Sanbo Kyodan mixes Sōtō and Rinzai-elements.Шаблон:Sfn Students in this school follow the Harada-Yasutani koan curriculum, in which great emphasis is placed on kensho, the initial insight into one's true nature.Шаблон:Sfn Having attained kensho is publicly acknowledged in a jahai-ceremony.Шаблон:Sfn After working through the Harada-Yasutani koan curriculum, which may take as short as five years,Шаблон:Sfn the student receives a calligraphy testifying that he or she "has finished the great matter".Шаблон:Sfn This is publicly acknowledged in the hasansai-ceremony, giving the status of hasan.Шаблон:Sfn
The Sanbo Kyodan has two levels of teaching authority, namely junshike ("associate zen master"), and shōshike ("authentic zen master").Шаблон:Sfn Junshikes can give dokusan, authorize kensho, and supervise part of the koan-study. Shoshikes can supervise the advanced koan-study, and perform religious ceremonies, such as the precept-ceremony and wedding ceremonies.Шаблон:Sfn
The process toward gaining these titles has seen some variations within the Sanbo Kyodan. Hasansai may be preparatory to the junshike-title, but may also be the promotion to this title. And promotion to shoshike may be preparatory to dharma transmission, but may also be equivalent to it.Шаблон:Sfn
In dharma transmission, the student receives the sanmotsu, akin to the Sōtō shiho ceremony.Шаблон:Sfn This is coupled with the Rinzai notion on inka.Шаблон:Sfn In Rinzai, only students who have completed the complete Rinzai koan curriculum and "are eligible to serve as sōdō roshi,Шаблон:Sfn that is, master of a training hall, in distinction from a common temple, receive inka. In the Sanbo Kyodan, inka is derived from Harada's Rinzai master Dokutan Sōsan.Шаблон:Sfn
White Plum Asanga
In the White Plum Asanga, Dharma transmission comes first, and qualifies one as a sensei.Шаблон:Sfn This may be followed by inka, the final acknowledgemment:Шаблон:SfnШаблон:Sfn[5] Шаблон:Quote
Korean Soen
In Korean Soen, Inka (In'ga) typically refers to the private acknowledgement of dharma transmission from a teacher to their student. "Transmission" is used to refer to the public ceremonial version of the same acknowledgement.
Both are considered equal in authority and "realization". A monk with either In'ga or the public "transmission" is qualified to hold the post of Soen Sa (seonsa; Шаблон:Lang; Шаблон:Script), or "Zen Master" for a temple, and give transmission to their own students (either, In'ga or public "transmission"). The majority of Zen Masters in Korea have only received, and only give In'ga, with the formal transmission ceremony being far more rare.[6]
In the Western Kwan Um School of Zen created by the Korean Zen Master Seung Sahn, "Inka" is granted to an individual who has completed their koan training and is granted the title Ji Do Poep Sa Nim (jido beopsa-nim; Шаблон:Lang; Шаблон:Script). Dharma transmission in the Kwan Um School of Zen comes after inka, denoting the individual is now a Soen Sa Nim.[7] Seung Sahn himself is quoted saying in reference to the administration of his Western organization, Шаблон:Quote
Vietnamese Thiền
Thích Nhất Hạnh has created a ritual known as "Lamp Transmission", making a teacher a dharmācārya—an individual with "limited teaching authority."[7] According to author James Ishmael Ford, Шаблон:Quote
Criticism
In the western understanding, dharma transmission stands solely for recognition of authentic insight, whereas in the Japanese monastery system dharma transmission is a formal notification that someone is fully qualified to take a leading role in this system.Шаблон:SfnШаблон:Sfn In the USA and Europe dharma transmission is linked to the unofficial title roshi, older teacher. In the Western understanding roshis are "part of a tradition that imputes to them quasi-divine qualities",Шаблон:Sfn someone who "is defined by simplicity, innocence, and lack of self-interest or desire".Шаблон:Sfn Nevertheless, the authorisation of teachers through dharma transmission does not mean that teachers are infallible,Шаблон:Sfn as is clear from the repeated appearance of scandals:Шаблон:Sfn Шаблон:Quote
According to Stuart Lachs, those scandals have also been possible because of the status given to roshis by dharma transmission, and "a desire for the master’s aura, recognition, and approval":Шаблон:Sfn Шаблон:Quote
See also
- In other religions
Notes
References
Web-references
Шаблон:Reflist
Sources
- Шаблон:Cite book
- Шаблон:Cite book
- Шаблон:Cite book
- Шаблон:Cite journal
- Шаблон:CitationШаблон:Dead link
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Cite book
- Шаблон:Cite book
- Шаблон:Cite journal
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Cite book
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Cite book
- Шаблон:Cite book
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Cite book
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Cite book
- Шаблон:Cite journal
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Cite book
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Cite book
- Шаблон:Cite book
- Шаблон:Cite web
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Cite book
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Citation
Further reading
Historiography
Contemporary practice
- Шаблон:CitationШаблон:Dead link
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Citation
- Шаблон:Citation
External links
- Roshi and His Teachers, Dharma Transmission,and the Rochester Zen Center Lineage Roshi Bodhin Kjolhede discusses lineage and Dharma transmission.
- Coming Down from the Zen Clouds:A Critique of the Current State of American Zen Stuart Lachs criticizes Dharma transmission in Zen
- Dharma Transmission & Succession, A Sweeping Zen Roundtable Discussion (Podcast) Erik Storlie, Myoan Grace Schireson and Eshu Martin discuss Dharma transmission & succession
- Sweeping Zen: Inka shomei
- Married monks?
- Erik Fraser Storlie: Lineage Delusions: Eido Shimano Roshi, Dharma Transmission, and American Zen
- Muho Noelke: What does it take to become a full-fledged Sōtō-shu priest and is it really worth the whole deal? Part 1 – 2 – 3 – 4 – 5 – 6 – 7 – 8 – 9 – 10
- The Formation of Soto Zen Priests in the West, A Dialogue
- James Ishmael Ford: Bodhisattva Ordination, Leadership Reform, and the Role of Zen Clerics in Japan
- Interview with Mel Weitsman
- Jeffrey S. Brooks, On Self-Ordination, taking the title Sotapanna (Stream Winner), beginning a new Vehicle of Buddhism and Using the Buddha's terminology for hierarchy within that new vehicle
Шаблон:Buddhism topics Шаблон:Zen
Ошибка цитирования Для существующих тегов <ref>
группы «web» не найдено соответствующего тега <references group="web"/>
- Английская Википедия
- Страницы с неработающими файловыми ссылками
- Buddhist philosophical concepts
- Zen Buddhist philosophical concepts
- Страницы, где используется шаблон "Навигационная таблица/Телепорт"
- Страницы с телепортом
- Википедия
- Статья из Википедии
- Статья из Английской Википедии
- Страницы с ошибками в примечаниях